VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG Review (from 06/05/2009 to 18/09/2009)During the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)I welcome and heartily approve this document! (Keith Noddle)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)I approve this document .(MireilleLouys)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)I approve this document (RayPlante)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)I approve (PedroOsuna)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)As already mentioned by Bob, Severin, Christophe, a pdf or html document is a requirement. "Andreas" is not the correct first name of the 6th author. Otherwise I approve the document. (FrancoisOchsenbein - 17 Sep 2009)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Approved provided that the remarks provided by other WGs/IGs are addressed, including provision of a pdf version.Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG Review (from 06/05/2009 to 18/09/2009)During the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)I welcome and heartily approve this document! (Keith Noddle)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)I approve this document .(MireilleLouys)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)I approve this document (RayPlante)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)I approve (PedroOsuna)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)As already mentioned by Bob, Severin, Christophe, a pdf or html document is a requirement. "Andreas" is not the correct first name of the 6th author. Otherwise I approve the document. (FrancoisOchsenbein - 17 Sep 2009)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Approved provided that the remarks provided by other WGs/IGs are addressed, including provision of a pdf version.Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | The list of 'standard' protocols is given in section 3.5. | |||||||
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for Comments | ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | This document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. | |||||||
> > | This document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. | |||||||
In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment.
Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.
Comments from the community
TCG Review (from 06/05/2009 to 18/09/2009)During the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)I welcome and heartily approve this document! (Keith Noddle)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)I approve this document .(MireilleLouys)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)I approve this document (RayPlante)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)I approve (PedroOsuna)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)As already mentioned by Bob, Severin, Christophe, a pdf or html document is a requirement. "Andreas" is not the correct first name of the 6th author. Otherwise I approve the document. (FrancoisOchsenbein - 17 Sep 2009)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Approved provided that the remarks provided by other WGs/IGs are addressed, including provision of a pdf version.Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | Done | |||||||
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | Done | |||||||
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | I don't have the source for this diagram anymore but will switch back to standard UML notation in the version. | |||||||
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | Done | |||||||
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | VOSpace 1.15 is transport protocol agnostic and does not mandate any particular protocol: these are understood to be implementation dependent. Protocols can be registered in the registry as VOStandards. | |||||||
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | No. | |||||||
| ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | ||||||||
> > | Reference added to SSO but there is no explicit mention of the RI standard in page 14 section 3.3.2. | |||||||
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG Review (from 06/05/2009 to 18/09/2009)During the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)I welcome and heartily approve this document! (Keith Noddle)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)I approve this document .(MireilleLouys)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)I approve this document (RayPlante)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | I approve (PedroOsuna) | |||||||
VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)As already mentioned by Bob, Severin, Christophe, a pdf or html document is a requirement. "Andreas" is not the correct first name of the 6th author. Otherwise I approve the document. (FrancoisOchsenbein - 17 Sep 2009)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Approved provided that the remarks provided by other WGs/IGs are addressed, including provision of a pdf version.Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
| ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | TCG Review | |||||||
> > | TCG Review (from 06/05/2009 to 18/09/2009) | |||||||
During the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:
Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)I welcome and heartily approve this document! (Keith Noddle)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)I approve this document .(MireilleLouys)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)I approve this document (RayPlante)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)As already mentioned by Bob, Severin, Christophe, a pdf or html document is a requirement. "Andreas" is not the correct first name of the 6th author. Otherwise I approve the document. (FrancoisOchsenbein - 17 Sep 2009)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Approved provided that the remarks provided by other WGs/IGs are addressed, including provision of a pdf version.Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)I welcome and heartily approve this document! (Keith Noddle)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)I approve this document .(MireilleLouys) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | ||||||||
Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)I approve this document (RayPlante)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)As already mentioned by Bob, Severin, Christophe, a pdf or html document is a requirement. "Andreas" is not the correct first name of the 6th author. Otherwise I approve the document. (FrancoisOchsenbein - 17 Sep 2009)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | Approved provided that the remarks provided by other WGs/IGs are addressed, including provision of a pdf version. | |||||||
Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)I welcome and heartily approve this document! (Keith Noddle)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards) | ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | ||||||||
> > | I approve this document .(MireilleLouys) | |||||||
Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)I approve this document (RayPlante)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)As already mentioned by Bob, Severin, Christophe, a pdf or html document is a requirement. "Andreas" is not the correct first name of the 6th author. Otherwise I approve the document. (FrancoisOchsenbein - 17 Sep 2009)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | I welcome and heartily approve this document! (Keith Noddle) | |||||||
Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)I approve this document (RayPlante)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)As already mentioned by Bob, Severin, Christophe, a pdf or html document is a requirement. "Andreas" is not the correct first name of the 6th author. Otherwise I approve the document. (FrancoisOchsenbein - 17 Sep 2009)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)I approve this document (RayPlante)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | As already mentioned by Bob, Severin, Christophe, a pdf or html document is a requirement. "Andreas" is not the correct first name of the 6th author. Otherwise I approve the document. (FrancoisOchsenbein - 17 Sep 2009) | |||||||
Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | I approve this document (RayPlante) | |||||||
Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)Approved.VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)I've added some comments on the GWS listVOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | Approved. | |||||||
VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | I've added some comments on the GWS list | |||||||
VOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)I approve this nice document.Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAMData Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)VOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi) | ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | ||||||||
> > | I approve this nice document. | |||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | ||||||||
Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available.Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name: | ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor) | |||||||
> > | Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor) | |||||||
I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way.
TAM
Data Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)VOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | Approved with the caveats as noted by Christophe and Severin below, and providing that a PDF version of the document is made available. | |||||||
Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | I approve this document. However I have been confused by the mismatch between the nominal VOSpace standard numbers and the document version. I don't know if that could be addressed in some simple way. TAM | |||||||
Data Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)VOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)Approved.TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)Data Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)VOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | Approved. | |||||||
TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear. I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)Data Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)VOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet) | ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | I appreciate the efforts from the editors for the updates between v1.14 and v1.15, so the VOSpace 1.15 document is self standing. | |||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | Although VOSpace 1.15 should probably be VOSpace 2.0 as it is not compatible with the previous REC VOSpace 1.0, I also mention here publicly that we agreed to leave this version to VOSpace 1.15 as it would be too difficult to change the existing implementations. This incompatibility is stated in page 1 so this is clear.
I approve the document with the minor questions/editorial comments:
| |||||||
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for Comments | ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | This document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. | |||||||
> > | This document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. | |||||||
In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment.
Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.
Comments from the community
TCG ReviewDuring the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)Data Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)VOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet)<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for Comments | ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | This document will act as RFC centre for the VOSpace 1.1 specification Proposed Recommendation v1.14. | |||||||
> > | This document completed its RFC period in October 2008. It is now undergoing TCG review. The specification is currently at Proposed Recommendation v.1.15. There are also machine readable files (WSDL and schema) available at the URL given in Appendix 1 of this document. | |||||||
Deleted: | ||||||||
< < | Review period: 2008 September 29 – 2008 October 27 | |||||||
In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment.
Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.
Comments from the community | ||||||||
Deleted: | ||||||||
< < |
| |||||||
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > |
| |||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | TCG Review | |||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | During the TCG review, Working and Interest Group chairs should add their comments under their name:
Applications (Tom McGlynn, Mark Taylor)Data Access Layer (Keith Noddle, Jesus Salgado)Data Model (Mireille Louys, Anita Richards)Grid & Web Services (Matthew Graham, Paul Harrison)I approve this document (MatthewGraham)Registry (Ray Plante, Aurelien Stebe)Semantics (Sebastien Derriere, Norman Gray)VOEvent (Rob Seaman, Alasdair Allan)VO Query Language (Pedro Osuna, Yuji Shirasaki)VOTable (Francois Ochsenbein)Standard and Processes (Francoise Genova)Astro RG (Masatoshi Ohishi)Data Curation & Preservation (Bob Hanisch)Theory (Herve Wozniak, Claudio Gheller)TCG (Christophe Arviset, Severin Gaudet) | |||||||
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document will act as RFC centre for the VOSpace 1.1 specification Proposed Recommendation v1.14. Review period: 2008 September 29 – 2008 October 27 In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > |
| |||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > | The utility wsdl2java from Axis2 doesn't work if these faults are missing. -- CyrilPestel | |||||||
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for Comments | ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | This document will act as RFC centre for the VOSpace 1.1 specification Proposed Recommendation v1.12. | |||||||
> > | This document will act as RFC centre for the VOSpace 1.1 specification Proposed Recommendation v1.14. | |||||||
Review period: 2008 September 29 – 2008 October 27
In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment.
Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.
Comments from the community
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for Comments | ||||||||
Changed: | ||||||||
< < | This document will act as RFC centre for the VOSpace 1.1 specification Proposed Recommendation v1.12. | |||||||
> > | This document will act as RFC centre for the VOSpace 1.1 specification Proposed Recommendation v1.12. | |||||||
Review period: 2008 September 29 – 2008 October 27
In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment.
Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.
Comments from the community
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document will act as RFC centre for the VOSpace 1.1 specification Proposed Recommendation v1.12. Review period: 2008 September 29 – 2008 October 27 In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
| ||||||||
Added: | ||||||||
> > |
| |||||||
<--
|
VOSpace 1.1 specification: Request for CommentsThis document will act as RFC centre for the VOSpace 1.1 specification Proposed Recommendation v1.12. Review period: 2008 September 29 – 2008 October 27 In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment. Discussions about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the VOSpace mailing list, vospace@ivoa.net.Comments from the community
<--
|