IdentifiersV110RFC < IVOA

---+  IVOA Identifiers V1.1 RFC

This document will act as *RFC* centre for the [[http://www.ivoa.net/Documents/latest/IDs.html]["IVOA Identifiers" v1.1]] (RayPlante, editor).

In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below in the format used for the example (include your TWiki.WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment.

Discussion about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the virtual observatory query language mailing list, registry@ivoa.net.

---++ Community Comments
   * First sample comment (by %MAINWEB%.TonyLinde): ...
      * Response (by _authorname_): ... 
---
   * At the Victoria interop I think we agreed that it would be a good idea to explicitly ban the use of "!" in identifiers, as that would have a special meaning in the VOSpace vos: scheme. The document as stands does not include this ban.
      * Accepted.  The ban has been included as requested.  (IVOA.RayPlante - 22 Aug 2006)

-- IVOA.PaulHarrison - 27 Jun 2006

Thre is still a little confusion in the revised document about whether "!" can appear in the resource key, although the ABNF list of reserved characters in version 3.1.1 now contains "!" the text that quotes them in the 2nd paragraph of 3.1.2 for the resource key does not - it would perhaps be better to remove the list in 3.1.2 and just make a link back to the ABNF.

-- IVOA.PaulHarrison - 12 Oct 2006

      *  thanks for pointing out this other location requiring the update; I will update accordingly.  I will certainly add the link; however, the text needs to refer to it in a non-hypertext way so that it is clear when reading a printed copy.  <br />  -- IVOA.RayPlante - 13 Oct 2006

---

---++ Comments from the Technical Coordination Group

TWG members should add their comments under their name.  The deadline for comments is 27 Oct 2006. 

---+++ Mark Allen (Applications IG)

I approve.

Minor textual comments:

Introduction:

of the first type describe above...

-> of the first type described above...

3.1.1

Incomplete sentence in the Note:

...;this practice has the advantage of reducing the probability that 
two authority ID.

3.3.2
Typo in the Note:
concatonated -> concatenated

---+++ Francoise Genova (Data Curation &amp; Preservation IG)

_please edit_

---+++ Bob Hanisch (Standards & Documentation WG)

Speaking with minimal/no authority, given that S&D WG is inactive, I approve and, like the others, only suggest that the typos be corrected.

---+++ Gerard Lemson (Theory IG)

_please edit_

---+++ Jonathan <nop>MacDowell (Data Models WG)

_please edit_

---+++ Reagan Moore (Data Curation &amp; Preservation IG)

I approve the recommendation.  There are a few minor typos that can be corrected:
section 1.0 - replace "control of provides" with "control provides"
section 3.1.2 - replace "has complete control their forms" with "has complete control of their forms"
section 3.2.2 - replace "that a URI that refers" with "that a URI refers"

---+++ Francois Ochsenbein (VOTable WG)

_please edit_

---+++ Pedro Osuna (VOQL WG)

_please edit_

---+++ Ray Plante (Resource Registry WG)

_Submitting Chair:_  no comments.

---+++ Andrea Priete-Martinez (Semantics WG)

I approve.

---+++ Guy Rixon (Grid &amp; Web Services WG)

_please edit_

---+++ Doug Tody (Data Access Layer WG)

_please edit_

---+++ Nic Walton (GGF Astro-RG)

_please edit_

---+++ Roy Williams (VOEvent WG)

_please edit_
This topic: IVOA > WebHome > IvoaResReg > IdentifiersV110RFC
Topic revision: r11 - 2006-10-23 - BobHanisch