InterOpOct2003DAL < IVOA

*Data Access Layer Working Group sessions Oct 16-17, 2003 at InterOpOct2003*

Chair: Doug Tody [DT]

Minutes: Markus Dolensky [MD]

There were about 40 participants.

For a review of the material covered and agreements reached see the [[%ATTACHURL%/DAL-WG-Summary.ppt][DAL WG summary presentation]] presented by D.Tody in Friday's plenary session.

---
Content:

%TOC%
---

---++ Overview of DAL types of data, DT

The concept of the class hierarchy of DAL services agreed to in Cambridge was
briefly reviewed.  See slide 10 in the [[%ATTACHURL%/DAL-WG-Summary.ppt][WG summary presentation]].

---++ SIA V1.1, DAL service infrastructure; key issues, DT

A number of active issues required for SIA V1.1 were discussed.
See slides 11-20 in the [[%ATTACHURL%/DAL-WG-Summary.ppt][WG summary presentation]].
<br>The issues discussed included:

   * dataset IDs including replica management, virtual data
   * component data models, data characterization, DM representation
   * access reference templating

Q: How to deal with uniqueness of a dataset identifier?<br>
A: Within authority ID domain data IDs assigned by each authority. One 'can' state  that a ID is a replica, but this is not ensured.

Q: How to state data quality?<br>
A1: Part of data model and characterization of data.<br>
A2: Resource metadata allows have basic quality description of data collection.

Q: What about IDs of OTF processed products?<br>
A: Goes to deeper question of what does it mean to publish data to the VO?<br>
IDs do not change, but data may go away.


---++ Proposed evolutions for SIA, Francois Bonnarel
   * URL templates to get less verbose output
   * factorization of repetitive cell values
   * data model serialization
   * Question: Would XSLT or Xpath be the right way to implement URL template resolution?
   * Francois asks for feedback to be sent to dal@ivoa.net

---++ SSA Overview, DT 

An introduction to the goals of the Simple Spectral Access interface (SSA) was presented.
See slides 21-28 in the [[%ATTACHURL%/DAL-WG-Summary.ppt][WG summary presentation]].

General Agreements on SSA:
   * Provide uniform interface for both 1D spectra and SEDs
   * Develop uniform data model for both 1D spectra and SEDs
   * Service interface will be similar to SIA, CS (query/response, getData)

Data output formats will include at least text, VOTable, FITS, graphicsSSA will provide an 
opportunity to learn how to 1) map VO data models into multiple external representations, 
and 2) package actual datasets in XML/VOTable, including representing data models in XML.


   * A [[SsaSurvey][survey among data providers and consumers]] was conducted earlier and will provide use cases to drive the interface design.


---++ SED Intro, MD
   * This lead to a discussion about properties and query parameters that SSA services should recognize and support. See presentation ([[%PUBURL%/%WEB%/IvoaDAL/dalsedspec.pdf][.pdf]], [[%PUBURL%/%WEB%/IvoaDAL/dalsedspec.ppt][.ppt]])
   * Some missing bits were identified:
      * definition how to group parameter blocks; i.e. chunks of points with common meta info
      * reference frame (e.g. velocity frame, rest frame)

---++ [[http://www.ivoa.net/forum/dm/0132.htm][Spectral Data Model]], Jonathan <nop>McDowell</nop>
   * follow above [[http://www.ivoa.net/forum/dm/0132.htm][link]] for intro to modeling effort
   * Suggestion: Use term "samples" 
   * Note that model also is supposed to cover SEDs

---++ SSA Issues (discussion)
   * add query parameter for spectral resolution
   * Suggestion: Find more use cases
   * About formats: VOtable, text, fits binary table or image, graphics

Q: Conversion support for units needed? <br>
A: No.



<!--
      * Set ALLOWTOPICRENAME = %MAINWEB%.TWikiAdminGroup
-->
Attachments
Topic attachments
I	Attachment	History	Action	Size	Date	Who	Comment
ppt	DAL-WG-Summary.ppt	r1	manage	987.5 K	2003-10-22 - 22:33	DougTody
This topic: IVOA > WebHome > IvoaEvents > InterOpOct2003 > InterOpOct2003DAL
Topic revision: r4 - 2003-10-22 - DougTody