Difference: TCGMeetingAgenda201005 (1 vs. 26)

Revision 262012-06-26 - root

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
Changed:
<
<
>
>
 
  1. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a Group 1 Group 2
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a VOArchitecture
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4 PPT
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d SED Builder / Search by list and by Object Type / VO Portal
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organization 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d TCG Org / Valid&Verif

Meeting Report given to the IVOA Exec on 16/05/2010

Changed:
<
<		See CA's presentation (PDF)
>
>		See CA's presentation (PDF)
 

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Francois VOTable
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274481949" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="657408" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.6"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226376" name="TCGOrg.pdf" path="TCGOrg.pdf" size="86442" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226400" name="ValidVerif.pdf" path="ValidVerif.pdf" size="97757" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226640" name="SEDBuilding.JPG" path="SEDBuilding.JPG" size="314119" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226707" name="SearchSourceClass.JPG" path="SearchSourceClass.JPG" size="283713" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"

Revision 252010-05-21 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a Group 1 Group 2
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a VOArchitecture
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4 PPT
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d SED Builder / Search by list and by Object Type / VO Portal
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organization 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d TCG Org / Valid&Verif

Meeting Report given to the IVOA Exec on 16/05/2010

See CA's presentation (PDF)

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Francois VOTable
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"
Changed:
<
<
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274449484" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="649728" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.5"
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274481949" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="657408" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.6"
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226376" name="TCGOrg.pdf" path="TCGOrg.pdf" size="86442" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226400" name="ValidVerif.pdf" path="ValidVerif.pdf" size="97757" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226640" name="SEDBuilding.JPG" path="SEDBuilding.JPG" size="314119" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226707" name="SearchSourceClass.JPG" path="SearchSourceClass.JPG" size="283713" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"

Revision 242010-05-21 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a Group 1 Group 2
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a VOArchitecture
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4 PPT
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d SED Builder / Search by list and by Object Type / VO Portal
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organization 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d TCG Org / Valid&Verif

Meeting Report given to the IVOA Exec on 16/05/2010

See CA's presentation (PDF)

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Francois VOTable
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"
Changed:
<
<
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274111021" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="771584" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.4"
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274449484" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="649728" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.5"
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226376" name="TCGOrg.pdf" path="TCGOrg.pdf" size="86442" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226400" name="ValidVerif.pdf" path="ValidVerif.pdf" size="97757" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226640" name="SEDBuilding.JPG" path="SEDBuilding.JPG" size="314119" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226707" name="SearchSourceClass.JPG" path="SearchSourceClass.JPG" size="283713" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"

Revision 232010-05-18 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
Changed:
<
<
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
>
>
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
 
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a Group 1 Group 2
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a VOArchitecture
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4 PPT
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
Changed:
<
<
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
>
>
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d SED Builder / Search by list and by Object Type / VO Portal
 
  15.30–16.00 Break
Changed:
<
<
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organization 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  
>
>
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organization 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d TCG Org / Valid&Verif
 

Meeting Report given to the IVOA Exec on 16/05/2010

See CA's presentation (PDF)

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Added:
>
>
Francois VOTable
 
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
Deleted:
<
<
Francois VOTable
 
Deleted:
<
<		On friday, the TCG was split into 2 groups for independent brainstorming on the VO architecture. This is what they came up with :
 
Deleted:
<
<
  • Group 1:
    group1_kw2.jpg
group1_kw2.jpg group1_kw3.jpg
group1_level0.jpg
 
Deleted:
<
<
  • Group 2:
    group2_kw1.jpg
group2_kw2.jpg group2_kw3.jpg group2_kw4.jpg group2_kw5.jpg
 
Deleted:
<
<
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
Deleted:
<
<
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273872984" name="group1_kw1.jpg" path="group1_kw1.jpg" size="69273" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873042" name="group1_kw2.jpg" path="group1_kw2.jpg" size="60948" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873083" name="group1_kw3.jpg" path="group1_kw3.jpg" size="49454" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
Deleted:
<
<
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873143" name="group2_kw1.jpg" path="group2_kw1.jpg" size="39474" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873175" name="group2_kw2.jpg" path="group2_kw2.jpg" size="48295" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873203" name="group2_kw3.jpg" path="group2_kw3.jpg" size="61268" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873244" name="group2_kw4.jpg" path="group2_kw4.jpg" size="50404" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873268" name="group2_kw5.jpg" path="group2_kw5.jpg" size="20822" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274111021" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="771584" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.4"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226376" name="TCGOrg.pdf" path="TCGOrg.pdf" size="86442" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226400" name="ValidVerif.pdf" path="ValidVerif.pdf" size="97757" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226640" name="SEDBuilding.JPG" path="SEDBuilding.JPG" size="314119" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274226707" name="SearchSourceClass.JPG" path="SearchSourceClass.JPG" size="283713" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
 

Revision 222010-05-17 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a Group 1 Group 2
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a VOArchitecture
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4 PPT
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organization 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Meeting Report given to the IVOA Exec on 16/05/2010

See CA's presentation (PDF)

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
Francois VOTable

On friday, the TCG was split into 2 groups for independent brainstorming on the VO architecture. This is what they came up with :

  • Group 1:
    group1_kw2.jpg
group1_kw2.jpg group1_kw3.jpg
group1_level0.jpg

  • Group 2:
    group2_kw1.jpg
group2_kw2.jpg group2_kw3.jpg group2_kw4.jpg group2_kw5.jpg

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273872984" name="group1_kw1.jpg" path="group1_kw1.jpg" size="69273" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873042" name="group1_kw2.jpg" path="group1_kw2.jpg" size="60948" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873083" name="group1_kw3.jpg" path="group1_kw3.jpg" size="49454" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873143" name="group2_kw1.jpg" path="group2_kw1.jpg" size="39474" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873175" name="group2_kw2.jpg" path="group2_kw2.jpg" size="48295" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873203" name="group2_kw3.jpg" path="group2_kw3.jpg" size="61268" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873244" name="group2_kw4.jpg" path="group2_kw4.jpg" size="50404" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873268" name="group2_kw5.jpg" path="group2_kw5.jpg" size="20822" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"
Changed:
<
<
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274104123" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="618496" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.3"
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274111021" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="771584" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.4"
 

Revision 212010-05-17 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a Group 1 Group 2
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a VOArchitecture
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4 PPT
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organization 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Meeting Report given to the IVOA Exec on 16/05/2010

See CA's presentation (PDF)

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
Francois VOTable

On friday, the TCG was split into 2 groups for independent brainstorming on the VO architecture. This is what they came up with :

  • Group 1:
    group1_kw2.jpg
group1_kw2.jpg group1_kw3.jpg
group1_level0.jpg

  • Group 2:
    group2_kw1.jpg
group2_kw2.jpg group2_kw3.jpg group2_kw4.jpg group2_kw5.jpg

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273872984" name="group1_kw1.jpg" path="group1_kw1.jpg" size="69273" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873042" name="group1_kw2.jpg" path="group1_kw2.jpg" size="60948" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873083" name="group1_kw3.jpg" path="group1_kw3.jpg" size="49454" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873143" name="group2_kw1.jpg" path="group2_kw1.jpg" size="39474" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873175" name="group2_kw2.jpg" path="group2_kw2.jpg" size="48295" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873203" name="group2_kw3.jpg" path="group2_kw3.jpg" size="61268" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873244" name="group2_kw4.jpg" path="group2_kw4.jpg" size="50404" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873268" name="group2_kw5.jpg" path="group2_kw5.jpg" size="20822" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"
Changed:
<
<
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274059816" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="570880" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274104123" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="618496" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.3"
 

Revision 202010-05-17 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
Changed:
<
<
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
>
>
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a Group 1 Group 2
 
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a VOArchitecture
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4 PPT
Changed:
<
<
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
>
>
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case 4a  
 
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
Changed:
<
<
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
>
>
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group 4a  
 
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
Changed:
<
<
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  
>
>
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organization 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  
 
Added:
>
>

Meeting Report given to the IVOA Exec on 16/05/2010

See CA's presentation (PDF)
 

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
Francois VOTable

On friday, the TCG was split into 2 groups for independent brainstorming on the VO architecture. This is what they came up with :

  • Group 1:
    group1_kw2.jpg
group1_kw2.jpg group1_kw3.jpg
group1_level0.jpg

  • Group 2:
    group2_kw1.jpg
group2_kw2.jpg group2_kw3.jpg group2_kw4.jpg group2_kw5.jpg
Deleted:
<
<
  • Interestingly, the two groups ended up with a 3-layers architecture:
    group1_3layers.jpg
group2_3layers.jpg
 
Added:
>
>
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273872984" name="group1_kw1.jpg" path="group1_kw1.jpg" size="69273" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873042" name="group1_kw2.jpg" path="group1_kw2.jpg" size="60948" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873083" name="group1_kw3.jpg" path="group1_kw3.jpg" size="49454" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873143" name="group2_kw1.jpg" path="group2_kw1.jpg" size="39474" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873175" name="group2_kw2.jpg" path="group2_kw2.jpg" size="48295" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873203" name="group2_kw3.jpg" path="group2_kw3.jpg" size="61268" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873244" name="group2_kw4.jpg" path="group2_kw4.jpg" size="50404" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873268" name="group2_kw5.jpg" path="group2_kw5.jpg" size="20822" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"
Changed:
<
<
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274058906" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="411648" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274059816" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="570880" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
 

Revision 192010-05-17 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
Changed:
<
<
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
>
>
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a VOArchitecture
 
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4 PPT
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
Francois VOTable

On friday, the TCG was split into 2 groups for independent brainstorming on the VO architecture. This is what they came up with :

  • Group 1:
    group1_kw2.jpg
group1_kw2.jpg group1_kw3.jpg
group1_level0.jpg

  • Group 2:
    group2_kw1.jpg
group2_kw2.jpg group2_kw3.jpg group2_kw4.jpg group2_kw5.jpg

  • Interestingly, the two groups ended up with a 3-layers architecture:
    group1_3layers.jpg
group2_3layers.jpg

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273872984" name="group1_kw1.jpg" path="group1_kw1.jpg" size="69273" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873042" name="group1_kw2.jpg" path="group1_kw2.jpg" size="60948" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873083" name="group1_kw3.jpg" path="group1_kw3.jpg" size="49454" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873143" name="group2_kw1.jpg" path="group2_kw1.jpg" size="39474" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873175" name="group2_kw2.jpg" path="group2_kw2.jpg" size="48295" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873203" name="group2_kw3.jpg" path="group2_kw3.jpg" size="61268" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873244" name="group2_kw4.jpg" path="group2_kw4.jpg" size="50404" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873268" name="group2_kw5.jpg" path="group2_kw5.jpg" size="20822" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1274058906" name="VOArchitecture.ppt" path="VOArchitecture.ppt" size="411648" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
 

Revision 182010-05-15 - PaoloPadovani

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
Changed:
<
<
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
>
>
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4 PPT
 
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
Francois VOTable

On friday, the TCG was split into 2 groups for independent brainstorming on the VO architecture. This is what they came up with :

  • Group 1:
    group1_kw2.jpg
group1_kw2.jpg group1_kw3.jpg
group1_level0.jpg

  • Group 2:
    group2_kw1.jpg
group2_kw2.jpg group2_kw3.jpg group2_kw4.jpg group2_kw5.jpg

  • Interestingly, the two groups ended up with a 3-layers architecture:
    group1_3layers.jpg
group2_3layers.jpg
Changed:
<
<
>
>
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273872984" name="group1_kw1.jpg" path="group1_kw1.jpg" size="69273" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873042" name="group1_kw2.jpg" path="group1_kw2.jpg" size="60948" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873083" name="group1_kw3.jpg" path="group1_kw3.jpg" size="49454" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873143" name="group2_kw1.jpg" path="group2_kw1.jpg" size="39474" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873175" name="group2_kw2.jpg" path="group2_kw2.jpg" size="48295" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873203" name="group2_kw3.jpg" path="group2_kw3.jpg" size="61268" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873244" name="group2_kw4.jpg" path="group2_kw4.jpg" size="50404" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873268" name="group2_kw5.jpg" path="group2_kw5.jpg" size="20822" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"

Revision 172010-05-15 - PaoloPadovani

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
Francois VOTable

On friday, the TCG was split into 2 groups for independent brainstorming on the VO architecture. This is what they came up with :

  • Group 1:
    group1_kw2.jpg
group1_kw2.jpg group1_kw3.jpg
group1_level0.jpg

  • Group 2:
    group2_kw1.jpg
group2_kw2.jpg group2_kw3.jpg group2_kw4.jpg group2_kw5.jpg

  • Interestingly, the two groups ended up with a 3-layers architecture:
    group1_3layers.jpg
group2_3layers.jpg
Added:
>
>
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273872984" name="group1_kw1.jpg" path="group1_kw1.jpg" size="69273" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873042" name="group1_kw2.jpg" path="group1_kw2.jpg" size="60948" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873083" name="group1_kw3.jpg" path="group1_kw3.jpg" size="49454" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873143" name="group2_kw1.jpg" path="group2_kw1.jpg" size="39474" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873175" name="group2_kw2.jpg" path="group2_kw2.jpg" size="48295" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873203" name="group2_kw3.jpg" path="group2_kw3.jpg" size="61268" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873244" name="group2_kw4.jpg" path="group2_kw4.jpg" size="50404" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873268" name="group2_kw5.jpg" path="group2_kw5.jpg" size="20822" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273945103" name="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" path="IVOA_ScienceInput_TCG_May2010.ppt" size="4329984" user="PaoloPadovani" version="1.1"
 

Revision 162010-05-15 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
Changed:
<
<
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
>
>
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )   PDF
 
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Deleted:
<
<
Pedro VOQL
 
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
Added:
>
>
Francois VOTable
 

On friday, the TCG was split into 2 groups for independent brainstorming on the VO architecture. This is what they came up with :

  • Group 1:
    group1_kw2.jpg
group1_kw2.jpg group1_kw3.jpg
group1_level0.jpg

  • Group 2:
    group2_kw1.jpg
group2_kw2.jpg group2_kw3.jpg group2_kw4.jpg group2_kw5.jpg

  • Interestingly, the two groups ended up with a 3-layers architecture:
    group1_3layers.jpg
group2_3layers.jpg

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273872984" name="group1_kw1.jpg" path="group1_kw1.jpg" size="69273" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873042" name="group1_kw2.jpg" path="group1_kw2.jpg" size="60948" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873083" name="group1_kw3.jpg" path="group1_kw3.jpg" size="49454" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873143" name="group2_kw1.jpg" path="group2_kw1.jpg" size="39474" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873175" name="group2_kw2.jpg" path="group2_kw2.jpg" size="48295" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873203" name="group2_kw3.jpg" path="group2_kw3.jpg" size="61268" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873244" name="group2_kw4.jpg" path="group2_kw4.jpg" size="50404" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873268" name="group2_kw5.jpg" path="group2_kw5.jpg" size="20822" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273942838" name="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" path="20100514TCGMeeting-Intro.pdf" size="396355" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
 

Revision 152010-05-14 - SebastienDerriere

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
Added:
>
>		On friday, the TCG was split into 2 groups for independent brainstorming on the VO architecture. This is what they came up with :

  • Group 1:
    group1_kw2.jpg
group1_kw2.jpg group1_kw3.jpg
group1_level0.jpg

  • Group 2:
    group2_kw1.jpg
group2_kw2.jpg group2_kw3.jpg group2_kw4.jpg group2_kw5.jpg

  • Interestingly, the two groups ended up with a 3-layers architecture:
    group1_3layers.jpg
group2_3layers.jpg
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273872984" name="group1_kw1.jpg" path="group1_kw1.jpg" size="69273" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873042" name="group1_kw2.jpg" path="group1_kw2.jpg" size="60948" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873083" name="group1_kw3.jpg" path="group1_kw3.jpg" size="49454" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873114" name="group1_level0.jpg" path="group1_level0.jpg" size="16807" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873143" name="group2_kw1.jpg" path="group2_kw1.jpg" size="39474" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873175" name="group2_kw2.jpg" path="group2_kw2.jpg" size="48295" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873203" name="group2_kw3.jpg" path="group2_kw3.jpg" size="61268" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873244" name="group2_kw4.jpg" path="group2_kw4.jpg" size="50404" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873268" name="group2_kw5.jpg" path="group2_kw5.jpg" size="20822" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873294" name="group1_3layers.jpg" path="group1_3layers.jpg" size="45788" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="Brain storming on VO architecture" date="1273873319" name="group2_3layers.jpg" path="group2_3layers.jpg" size="46496" user="SebastienDerriere" version="1.1"
 

Revision 142010-05-14 - SeverinGaudet

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion
Changed:
<
<
>
>
 

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"

Revision 132010-05-14 - SeverinGaudet

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)
Changed:
<
<

Draft Meeting Agenda

>
>

Meeting Agenda

 
Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
Added:
>
>
  19.00- Dinner: Heron Rock Bistro
 
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"

Revision 122010-05-05 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
Changed:
<
<
    • [[][List of Standards under development]]
>
>
 
  1. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Draft Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273064133" name="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsInProgressMay2010.pdf" size="13838" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
 

Revision 112010-05-05 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
Changed:
<
<
    • [[][List of Recommended Standards]]
>
>
 
    • [[][List of Standards under development]]
  1. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Draft Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1273057441" name="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" path="ListIVOAStandardsMay2010.pdf" size="15499" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.1"
 

Revision 102010-04-19 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Draft Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Mark Apps
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Deleted:
<
<
Norman Semantics
 
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"

Revision 92010-04-16 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Draft Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Added:
>
>
Mark Apps
 
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Norman Semantics
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"

Revision 82010-04-16 - SeverinGaudet

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)
Changed:
<
<

Draft Meeting Agenda

>
>

Draft Meeting Agenda

 
Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Norman Semantics
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"

Revision 72010-04-15 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Changed:
<
<
>
>
 

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
  2. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
  5. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)

Draft Meeting Agenda

Fri May 14 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Norman Semantics
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"

Revision 62010-04-14 - SeverinGaudet

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

Changed:
<
<
>
>
  1. Documents relevant to the architecture and science case discussions
Added:
>
>
    • [[][List of Standards under development]]
  1. Documents relevant to the TCG organization discussion
 

Meeting Objectives

Changed:
<
<
  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture
>
>
  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
 
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
Changed:
<
<
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status
>
>
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture (Session 4)
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status (Session 4)
 
  1. For each upcoming IVOA standard
Changed:
<
<
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard
  2. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities (Sessions 5–7)
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards
>
>
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture (Sessions 1-3)
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard (Session 4)
  2. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these (Sessions 5–7)
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards (Sessions 5–7)
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards (Sessions 5–7)
Deleted:
<
<
    1. have this endorsed by IVOA exec
 
  1. TCG organization (Session 8)
Changed:
<
<
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter?
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package" (see CA's email on 14/11/2008)
>
>
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification? (Session 8)
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter? (Session 8)
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard? (Session 8)
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package"? (Session 8)
 

Draft Meeting Agenda

Added:
>
>
Fri May 14 2010
 
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
Deleted:
<
<
Fri May 14 2010
 
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
Changed:
<
<
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a Brainstorming on current architecture
>
>
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a, 2a, 3a Brainstorming on current architecture
 
  10.30–11.00 Break
Changed:
<
<
2 11.00–11.30 Presentations by breakout group 1a  
11.30–12.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a  
>
>
2 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 1a, 2a, 3a  
12.00–12.30 Presentations by each group 1a, 2a, 3a  
 
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
Changed:
<
<
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a  
>
>
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a, 2a, 3a  
 
  15.30–16.00 Break
Changed:
<
<
4 16.00–17.00 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a  
17.00–17.30 Finalization of architectures 1a  
Action plan for updating IVOA standards 1a  
>
>
4 16.00–17.30 Plan for updating IVOA standards 2b, 2c, 3b  
Sat May 15 2010
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
Deleted:
<
<
Sat May 15 2010
 
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
Changed:
<
<
7 14.00–15.30   4b, 4c, 4d  
>
>
7 14.00–15.30 Science case priorities and responsibilities 4b, 4c, 4d  
 
  15.30–16.00 Break
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Norman Semantics
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"

Revision 52010-04-14 - SeverinGaudet

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture
Changed:
<
<
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
>
>
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
 
  1. For each existing IVOA standard,
Changed:
<
<
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status
>
>
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status
 
  1. For each upcoming IVOA standard
Changed:
<
<
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard
  2. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards
    4. have this endorsed by IVOA exec
  3. TCG organisation
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter?
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package" (see CA's email on 14/11/2008)
>
>
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard
  2. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities (Sessions 5–7)
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards
    4. have this endorsed by IVOA exec
  3. TCG organization (Session 8)
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter?
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package" (see CA's email on 14/11/2008)
 

Draft Meeting Agenda

Changed:
<
<
Time Session Objectives Notes
>
>
Session Time Topic Objectives Notes
 
Fri May 14 2010
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
Changed:
<
<
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin )   Brainstorming on current architecture
>
>
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin ) 1a Brainstorming on current architecture
 
  10.30–11.00 Break
Changed:
<
<
2 11.00–11.30 Presentations by breakout group    
11.30–12.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures    
>
>
2 11.00–11.30 Presentations by breakout group 1a  
11.30–12.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a  
 
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
Changed:
<
<
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures    
>
>
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a  
 
  15.30–16.00 Break
Changed:
<
<
4 16.00–17.00 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures    
17.00–17.30 Finalization of architectures    
Action plan for updating IVOA standards    
>
>
4 16.00–17.00 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures 1a  
17.00–17.30 Finalization of architectures 1a  
Action plan for updating IVOA standards 1a  
 
Sat May 15 2010
Changed:
<
<
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo)    
>
>
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo) 4  
Added:
>
>
09.45–10.30 Breakout 1 group per science case (x3) 4a  
 
  10.30–11.00 Break
Changed:
<
<
6 11.00–12.30      
>
>
6 11.00–12.00 Breakout groups continued 4a  
Added:
>
>
12.00–12.30 Presentation by each group (x3) 4a  
 
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
Changed:
<
<
7 14.00–15.30 Points 4.iii and 4    
>
>
7 14.00–15.30   4b, 4c, 4d  
 
  15.30–16.00 Break
Changed:
<
<
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation    
>
>
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation 5a, 5b, 5c, 5d  
 

Participants

Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Norman Semantics
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"

Revision 42010-04-14 - SeverinGaudet

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

Changed:
<
<
>
>
Added:
>
>
  • [[][List of Recommended Standards]]
  • [[][List of Standards under development]]
 

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture
Changed:
<
<
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs
>
>
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption (Level 0) and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs (Level 1)
 
  1. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status
  2. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard
  3. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards
    4. have this endorsed by IVOA exec
Changed:
<
<
  1. Other topics
>
>
  1. TCG organisation
 
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter?
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package" (see CA's email on 14/11/2008)
Changed:
<
<

Meeting Agenda

>
>

Draft Meeting Agenda

 
Changed:
<
<
Time Session Notes
Fri May 14 2010
09.00–09.15 Welcome and Logistics  
09.15–09.30 Review of Agenda  
09.30–10.00 Overview of architecture  
10.00–11.00 Break out groups  
10.30–11.00 Break
11.00–12.30    
12.30–14.00 Lunch
14.00–15.30    
15.30–16.00 Break
16.00–17.30    
Sat May 15 2010
09.00–10.30    
10.30–11.00 Break
11.00–12.30    
12.30–14.00 Lunch
14.00–15.30    
15.30–16.00 Break
16.00–17.30    
>
>
Time Session Objectives Notes
Fri May 14 2010
1 09.00–09.05 Welcome and Logistics    
09.05–09.30 Meeting introduction and objectives (Christophe )    
09.30–10.30 Breakout into two groups (Christophe and Sιverin )   Brainstorming on current architecture
  10.30–11.00 Break
2 11.00–11.30 Presentations by breakout group    
11.30–12.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures    
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
3 14.00–15.30 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures    
  15.30–16.00 Break
4 16.00–17.00 Definition of Level 0 and Level 1 architectures    
17.00–17.30 Finalization of architectures    
Action plan for updating IVOA standards    
Sat May 15 2010
5 09.00–09.45 IVOA Science Cases (Paolo)    
  10.30–11.00 Break
6 11.00–12.30      
  12.30–14.00 Lunch
7 14.00–15.30 Points 4.iii and 4    
  15.30–16.00 Break
Added:
>
>
8 16.00–17.30 TCG organisation    
 
Added:
>
>

Participants

 
Changed:
<
<		 


<--  
-->
>
>
Christophe TCG
Fabio IVOA
Franηoise S&P
Hervι Theory
Jesus DAL
Keith DAL
Matthew GWS
Mireille DM
Added:
>
>
Norman Semantics
Paolo IVOA
Pedro VOQL
Ray Registry
Rob VOEvent
Sebastien Semantics
Sιverin TCG
Tom Apps
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"

Revision 32010-04-14 - ChristopheArviset

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading

Changed:
<
<
  • EuroVO Reference Architecture 2009
>
>
 

Meeting Objectives

  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards
    4. have this endorsed by IVOA exec
  5. Other topics
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter?
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package" (see CA's email on 14/11/2008)

Meeting Agenda

Time Session Notes
Fri May 14 2010
09.00–09.15 Welcome and Logistics  
09.15–09.30 Review of Agenda  
09.30–10.00 Overview of architecture  
10.00–11.00 Break out groups  
10.30–11.00 Break
11.00–12.30    
12.30–14.00 Lunch
14.00–15.30    
15.30–16.00 Break
16.00–17.30    
Sat May 15 2010
09.00–10.30    
10.30–11.00 Break
11.00–12.30    
12.30–14.00 Lunch
14.00–15.30    
15.30–16.00 Break
16.00–17.30     


<--  
-->
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="h" comment="" date="1271237701" name="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" path="VOTECH-reference-architecture-20090630.pdf" size="81679" user="ChristopheArviset" version="1.2"
 

Revision 22010-04-14 - SeverinGaudet

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.
Changed:
<
<

Recommended Reading Material

* Virtual Observatory Architecture Overview * The IVOA in 2009: Technical Assessment and RoadMap * EuroVO Reference Architecture * Standard Recommended or Under Development
>
>

Recommended Reading

 

Meeting Objectives

Added:
>
>
  1. Review and update IVOA top level architecture
    1. Two views required: one for public consumption and another to serve the needs of the WGs/IGs
  2. For each existing IVOA standard,
    1. determine where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine if a minor update is required wrt general introduction and situation within the IVOA top level architecture
    3. determine if a major update is required to reflect current IVOA status
  3. For each upcoming IVOA standard
    1. indicate general introduction and where it fits in the IVOA top level architecture
    2. determine WGs that should be involved in writing this standard
  4. Based on Science use cases delivered by the IVOA Committee on Science Priorities
    1. determine which IVOA standards would be required to address these
    2. determine priority amongst various on-going IVOA standards
    3. determine WGs that should be involved in writing these standards
    4. have this endorsed by IVOA exec
  5. Other topics
    1. how to handle Validation and Verification
    2. do we need to update the TCG charter?
    3. do we need to update the IVOA Document Standard
    4. do we need to update the WG/IG chair "induction package" (see CA's email on 14/11/2008)
 

Meeting Agenda

Time Session Notes
Fri May 14 2010
09.00–09.15 Welcome and Logistics  
09.15–09.30 Review of Agenda  
09.30–10.00 Overview of architecture  
10.00–11.00 Break out groups  
10.30–11.00 Break
11.00–12.30    
12.30–14.00 Lunch
14.00–15.30    
15.30–16.00 Break
16.00–17.30    
Sat May 15 2010
09.00–10.30    
10.30–11.00 Break
11.00–12.30    
12.30–14.00 Lunch
14.00–15.30    
15.30–16.00 Break
16.00–17.30     


<--  
-->

Revision 12010-04-14 - SeverinGaudet

 
META TOPICPARENT name="IvoaTCG"

IVOA Technical Coordination Meeting

May 14-15, 2010: Victoria, Canada

Local Arrangements

The meeting will be held in the Harbour Room of the Laurel Point Inn, the same venue as the IVOA Interoperability Meeting. Hotel information can be found here.

Recommended Reading Material

* Virtual Observatory Architecture Overview * The IVOA in 2009: Technical Assessment and RoadMap * EuroVO Reference Architecture * Standard Recommended or Under Development

Meeting Objectives

Meeting Agenda

Time Session Notes
Fri May 14 2010
09.00–09.15 Welcome and Logistics  
09.15–09.30 Review of Agenda  
09.30–10.00 Overview of architecture  
10.00–11.00 Break out groups  
10.30–11.00 Break
11.00–12.30    
12.30–14.00 Lunch
14.00–15.30    
15.30–16.00 Break
16.00–17.30    
Sat May 15 2010
09.00–10.30    
10.30–11.00 Break
11.00–12.30    
12.30–14.00 Lunch
14.00–15.30    
15.30–16.00 Break
16.00–17.30     


<--  
-->
View topic | History: r26 < r25 < r24 < r23 | More topic actions...
 
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by Perl This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platformCopyright © 2008-2025 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback