Resource Metadata RFC

This document will act as RFC centre for the Resource Metadata v1.1 Proposed Recommendation.

In order to add a comment to the document, please edit this page and add your comment to the list below in the format used for the example (include your WikiName so authors can contact you for further information). When the author(s) of the document have considered the comment, they will provide a response after the comment.

Discussion about any of the comments or responses should be conducted on the virtual observatory query language mailing list, registry@ivoa.net.

Community Comments

• First sample comment (by MarcoLeoni): ...
  • Response (by authorname): ...

• Second sample comment (): ...

Comments from the Technical Coordination Group

TWG members should add their comments under their name. The deadline for comments is 27 Oct 2006.

Note: RM v1.01 is a REC already; see sect. 7 for summary of changes since then.

Marc Allen (Applications IG)

please edit

Francoise Genova (Data Curation & Preservation IG)

please edit

Bob Hanisch (Standards & Documentation WG)

please edit

Gerard Lemson (Theory IG)

please edit

Jonathan McDowell (Data Models WG)

In section 3.2, I don't like the idea that there is Creator and Creator.Logo. I'd like these fields to be the utypes of the data model for RM, and that would be cleaner if you either change Creator to Creator.Name or change Creator.Logo to CreatorLogo (no dot).

You have ReferenceURL which must be a URL, but I think there also ought to be a ReferenceBibcode and I don't see one.

I realize these technical comments are late, and I will approve the rec even if you choose not to adopt them.

Reagan Moore (Data Curation & Preservation IG)

please edit

Francois Ochsenbein (VOTable WG)

please edit

Pedro Osuna (VOQL WG)

please edit

Ray Plante (Resource Registry WG)

Submitting Chair: no comments.

Andrea Priete-Martinez (Semantics WG)

I approve.

Guy Rixon (Grid & Web Services WG)

please edit

Doug Tody (Data Access Layer WG)

please edit

Nic Walton (GGF Astro-RG)

please edit

Roy Williams (VOEvent WG)

In section 3.2, for Contact information, I think there should be a place for telephone number. Also, I think multiple telephone numbers and emails should be allowed. This is because VOEvent schema clones the Contact schema from RM, and in that case it would be crucial to be able to contact the author of an event.

Once this change is made, I would add my vote for Recommendation.