TWiki> IVOA Web>IvoaStdsDocsProc>DocStd13 (revision 2)EditAttach

Discussion of Document Standards V1.3 >V2.0


Create a new endorsement track for errata, implementation notes, etc ('Strong Notes'), as discussed during the May 2014 Interop TCG meeting.

Pre-WD versions

This version was discussed at the TCG meeting during the Cape Town Interoperability meeting (8 May 2016). It was decided
    • To update the version number to 2.0
    • To implement Endorsed Notes with eventually a Proposed Endorsed Note phase, in particular when the TCG decides to launch a RfC
    • To implement errata

  • 30 August 2016 .pdf
Version sent to the TCG for comments on 30 August 2016 with the following comments:
    • At present the document states that there will be a link to the errata in the standard landing page and also in the standard document itself. This is more work for the Document Coordinator but it is a way to keep track closely about the current status of the standard. This was discussed already in the TCG and some of you thought it could be sufficient to have a link in the landing page. We have to take a decision.
    • Again to improve the errata traceability, Marco proposes to add an extension to the document number when there is an erratum, incremented each time a list of errata is added by the TCG. REC NN.MM would become REC NN.MM.1 after a first set of errata is approved, then NN.MM.2 after the second set, etc. This would allow the document including the successive errata to appear in the Technical specification list This is not included in the document for the moment. I personnally like the suggestion but your comments are welcome.
Topic attachments
I Attachment Action Size Date Who Comment
Microsoft Word filedoc Note-DocStd-1.3-20140928.doc manage 265.5 K 2014-09-30 - 07:24 FrancoiseGenova V1.3, 28 Sept 2014
PDFpdf Note-DocStd-1.3-20140928.pdf manage 358.0 K 2014-09-30 - 07:24 FrancoiseGenova V1.3, 28 Sept. 2014
PDFpdf Note-DocStd-1.3-20140928_withchanges.pdf manage 325.7 K 2014-09-30 - 07:25 FrancoiseGenova V1.3, 28 Sept. 2014
PDFpdf Note-DocStd-1_3-20160503.pdf manage 263.2 K 2016-08-30 - 08:59 FrancoiseGenova  
PDFpdf WD-DocStd-2.0-20160830.pdf manage 255.9 K 2016-08-30 - 09:10 FrancoiseGenova  
Microsoft Word filedoc WD-DocStd-2.0-20160830_old.doc manage 313.0 K 2016-08-30 - 09:10 FrancoiseGenova  
Edit | Attach | Print version | History: r3 < r2 < r1 | Backlinks | Raw View | Raw edit | More topic actions...
Topic revision: r2 - 2016-08-30 - FrancoiseGenova
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platformCopyright © 2008-2021 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback