ADASS XXI BoF : Scientific Workflows in Astronomy


Discussion points

  • How to boost the creation / sharing of Wfs knowledge in our community ?
    • People could be reluctant to fill with care the information required as part of the workflow preservation (data used, services, references, etc.) or to make the effort to ensure that it is reusable by others
  • Wf4Ever is a European project with a limited time life
    • How to preserve Wfs on the long term ? What kind of things (user datasets, methodology, tools for backward compatibility, Licenses??, etc.)
  • What can we learnt / what have we learned from other communities ?
  • Publishing Wfs : review methods (peer review, volunteer, etc.)
  • What parameters would you use to rate a Wf ? Or which ones would you like a rating system to provide you, so that you can select based on their quality / rating ?

Questions and Comments

  • Eric N. (Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory): R has facility for reproducible research
    • Data linked with method in same document
  • Alberto A. (CfA, ADS): big difference between high throughput, and group of people working on different smaller steps;
    • In Wf4Ever we are eating our own dog food
  • Petr S.: we are moving in spirals, mainframes, PCs, clouds
    • Services providers then have to bore the load of providing those computing facilities
  • Doug M. (SAO): Workflows as mean of structured communication between users and facilities
  • Rating workflows:
    • rate according to how can it hold delta changes in data
  • Adriaan R. (ASTRON): there is no way astronomers trust someone other than themselves. *having ways to assess authorship might allay some concerns.

Topic attachments
I Attachment History Action Size Date Who Comment
PDFpdf ADASS-2011-BoF.pdf r1 manage 174.1 K 2011-11-23 - 14:17 AndreSchaaff  
PDFpdf ADASS.Wf4Ever.pdf r1 manage 2281.3 K 2011-11-23 - 14:02 AndreSchaaff  
PDFpdf ADASS_BOF_Workflows_2011_Maisala.pdf r1 manage 3860.5 K 2011-11-23 - 14:18 AndreSchaaff  
PDFpdf BOFB4.cs.pdf r1 manage 1623.4 K 2011-11-23 - 14:03 AndreSchaaff  
PDFpdf OWL.pdf r1 manage 1505.7 K 2011-11-23 - 14:03 AndreSchaaff  
Edit | Attach | Watch | Print version | History: r3 < r2 < r1 | Backlinks | Raw View | Raw edit | More topic actions
Topic revision: r3 - 2012-05-21 - AndreSchaaff
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by Perl This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platformCopyright © 2008-2024 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback